I remember having read this post before I went to Coco Reef in november last year. I promised myself i wanted to write in it when I came home. It's been a while, but now I'm doing it. Let me explain what excactly happens in Tamaras when it comes to dress code (as of my experience there):
First of all - I had a marvellous time in Tobago. It was fantastic. I cannot recommend it enough. I could go on for hours. Please don't let the following disturb your plans, I just want you to know it, since it was a doubt I had as well before going.
Tamaras is a great resturant. They do have a dress code. The dress code is:
Men:
1. No jeans
2. No short trousers
3. No shirts without collar
4. decent shoes
Women:
Apparantly none.
Unfortunately - but understandable - there is noone at Tamaras to be a fashion judge. Nobody is capable of determining "ok, this guy looks like a million pounds" - they only have these 4 guidelines and they follow them strictly. If you do too, you'll have no problem. And they are quite easy to follow. A pair of black shoes, some sand-coloured slacks and a pink lacoste t-shirt (polo) will do. As long as it is coherent with the 4 rules.
On our first night (jetlagged, flying several hours, confused, just arrived, you know) we had decided to go to 'the other resturant' - but it was closed because of heavy rain (just that night, luckily) and therefore we 'had to' go to Tamaras. I was wearing black Armani Jeans (you cannot tell it's jeans unless you look closely) a striped T-shirt and a jacket + black italian designer shoes (my traveling outfit

). In my own opinon I could have been voted best dressed that night

(!) But that does not count. It was denim trousers and there was no collar on my t-shirt.
We took the chance ("chance" - having read this post) and were turned away. I then quickly ran to our room, found some black non-jeans-trousers with stripes (the bottom-half of a suit) and a short-sleeved very old and outworn shirt which I had brought for the beach in case of too much sun. I looked a complete mess and felt bad in it, but then it was okay.
I was seated next to a girl who looked like she was really into heavy metal music or shooting a horror movie. She had a tatoo across her bare back, a ring in her lower lip and wore black make up.
I honestly believe that if I had put on my pyjama to Tamaras, they would have let me in. As long as it is not jeans, shirt without collar, short trousers + with decent shoes. For girls it seems there is no dress code what so ever.
I'd like to stress out that we had the time of our lives. Tamaras is a fabolous resturant. Coco Reef is absolutely excellent. But it's not a dress code - it's a principle. Nobody's going to determine if you are looking good or not. They just follow the 4 steps they have been told to follow. You do that too!
